CUNY Math Challenge Blog

Solutions, Resources, Further Information & Discussion

Round 3: Problem 2 Solution

leave a comment »

Let’s call the maximum size a “sweet” set can have n, and let us try to find an upper bound for n.

Assume we have a set S of size n with distinct positive integer elements. Let’s construct a set, say S', with the elements of S \bmod 3.

Note a few important points:

  • All elements of S' are either {0, 1, 2}.
  • If S' contains three of the same element, those three elements would sum to 0 \bmod 3 which would mean that those three elements could not sum to a prime.
  • If S' contains one element each of {0, 1, 2}, then those three elements would sum to 0 \bmod3.
  • All elements of the original set S sum to at least 6 because we can have only distinct positive integers in S.

Therefore, S can contain at most 2 elements that are congruent mod 3 for at most 2 different possible remainders, meaning that our upper bound cannot be larger than 4 (otherwise at least one of the two conditions must fail). What is left is to see if there exists such a set of size 4, which indeed there are many, for example {1, 3, 7, 9}.

Written by Administrator

April 13, 2009 at 00:01

Posted in Round 3

Tagged with , ,

Leave a comment